| |
| Graft
estimates
|
| |
| The Do-it-yourself
graft estimation method |
I think it will be
best learnt by carrying out an actual exercise in estimation
of the optimum graft requirement for a particular person.
The first step is to see the donor area and determine the
skin and hair characteristics.
(1). Curly
/ straight. (2).
hair color. (3).
skin color (and thereby the skin-hair color contrast).
(4). hair shaft diameter (thick, thin or medium thickness
of the hair shaft).
Following are a few pics.
You can follow the same steps for yourself that we perform
for this case.
In case you have any queries or questions you can ask me
in this thread or you can email me at poswalarvind@yahoo.co.in |
| |
| |
| |
In the next step,
we calculate the actual donor area in sq.cms
One does not have to be a mathematical genius here- we are
aiming to get a rough idea about the grafts required. For
purpose of this case the area can be divided into the back
half and the front half.The back half can be measured easily
as almost a square / rectangle. |
| |
|
| |
It is approx. 11 cms
by 8 cms.
Area = 11 x 8 = 88 sq cms.
|
|
|
 |
|
 |
| |
| |
| |
We
Accept |
|
|
|
| |
| |
|
|
| |
For purpose of simplicity of calculation
let us consider it as 90 sq.cms
The area in front of this can be viewed as more of a triangle. |
|
| That will
be 11 cms (the base of the triangle) and 6 cms (the height
of the triangle).
Area of triangle = 1/2 x base x height
= 1/2 x 11cm x 6cm
= 33 sq.cms
Remember we have not included the hairline zone as yet.
The area to cover till now becomes 33sq.cm. + 90sq.cm. = 123sq.cms.
This area can vary in people with similar looking stage of
hair loss. The next step is to take care of the variables
in terms of the hair color, curl, shaft diameter etc.
For this purpose, you may trim hair over 1sq.cm. of the non
balding scalp.
And measure the FUs in 1sq.cm.
We have trimmed hair of this patient prior to his procedure.
You may count his FUs as nature gave them.
He is a native of Spain but lives in Australia.
His hair color is dark brown.
He has a fair skin.
He has straight, medium thickness - shaft diameter wise, hair.
The skin - hair color contrast is on the higher side.
I think a person who gets the knack of this method can not
be duped by a salesman consultant into believing that 1000
grafts would be enough for him, if his hair loss matches that
of the current patient.
Following is the pic of his donor area.
Please do check out the no. of FU's per sq. cm. |
|
We have to take into
account the 10% hair that may be in telogen and may have shed.
Similarly, we have to add 10% to the figure as the person
has a reasonably higher degree of skin hair color contrast.
If he has very thin / fine hair we will have to add another
10% to the final figure.
Like the hairline and the temples, the crown whorl area (though
comparatively small) also needs to be treated differently.
In the whorl, the hair all point in a centripetal way and
the center of the whorl has more 1 hair FUs than 2 hair ones.
For people with thin straight hair and high degree of skin
hair color contrast, a circle of roughly 2 cm diameter should
have the graft estimated in a way similar to that done for
the hairline.
For people with curly, coarse hair or lower degree of skin
hair color contrast, a 1 cm diameter circle will do.
After we have done the calculation for the 2 areas mentioned
above we calculate the hairline zone.
Following are the pics of the hairline proposed at present. |
|
We plan to keep a 1cm.
zone of mostly 1 hair FUs.
Following are pics of the last day of the patient's surgery.
We placed 2620 grafts over 42 sq.cms(approx 60 grafts per
sq. cm.)
The hairline was filled with mostly 1 hair FUs at 70 grafts
per sq. cm. whereas the inner areas were filled with 2 - 3
hair FUs (some very few 4 hair ones too) at 40 FUs per sq.cm
The grafts could have been placed at a higher density. But
one has to weigh the actual cosmetic benefit achieved to the
fact that there would be a donor depletion by the time we
try to fill up the remaining areas in his next trip. |
| |
Why did you not deal
with the crown as well ?
The patient wanted to go for 2500 grafts at present, not 5000
or more.
He, therefore, had 2 options -
1. To spread the grafts
thinly over the entire area - including crown, and then to
get more hair transplanted later in between the previously
transplanted area.
2. To dense pack one
area - the front - and to take care of the crown at a future
session.
He chose the second option. Another factor was that he wanted
to see the results of his body hair transplant (we placed
300+ grafts) and then in the 2nd session, he may opt only
for a body hair transplant and not touch his head donor area
again.
One of the questions that often comes up is how many grafts
per sq. cm.?
There is a lot of confusion in the mind of a newly balding
person.
30 grafts or 130 grafts per sq. cm.?
I think it needs to be addressed.
How much do you think is the no. of grafts per sq. cm. in
this person ?
Will the density, in your opinion, be satisfactory ? |
| |
Graft estimation charts are available
but the logic behind the graft estimates is not explained. Mostly,
they are subjective.
Secondly, the graft estimation charts are of a very generalised
nature. That is to say, the variables of the particular patient |
- Hair color.
- Hair shaft diameter.
- Skin hair color contrast.
- Hair curl / wave.
- Location of the hair loss.
- Patient expectations / aspirations.
|
are not objectively
taken into account. |
There is a way to be able to objectively
calculate what the patient may require for a full looking
head. No selective lighting, no combovers.
One way to account for most of the variables is to see one's
own donor area (at the back of the head) or the non balding
areas.
Comparing one's own non balding areas removes the problems
of many of the variables (hair color, curl, shaft diameter
etc.).
Q1. Does
the density in the scalp donor areas satisfy you ?
Most / all will be very happy to get similar looking hair
growth in their presently balding zone.
The minimum no. of FUs required to achieve that look will
be the optimum / maximum no. of grafts a person may require.
Now we have to calculate that "optimal
graft requirement".
The first step towards calculating that will be (if the answer
to Q1. is yes) to count the FUs per sq. cm. in that area.
You can do this yourself or with the help of one of your friend.
Trim hair over 1 sq. cm. and photograph with a good camera.
Load the image in the computer.
Open it in paint or photoshop. Choose a pencil marker tool
and count the FUs as they emerge from the scalp.
Let us assume a person X has 70 FUs per sq.cm. in the non
balding / scalp - donor area. 50% of the density of the donor
area will give a visual appearance of a non balding head (as
per studies already carried out by previous hair transplant
doctors).
That will come to 35 FUs per sq. cm.
Since the person is checking out his own hair, all variables
like hair curl, color etc. are accounted for.
Now we calculate the actual area of hair loss in sq. cm.
Please omit the hairline
zone and the temple areas presently.Their calculation be separate.
Supposing a NW 5 / 6 has 200 sq. cm.
of bald scalp. His Optimum graft requirement will be
35FUs x 200sq.cm. = 7000 FU grafts.
The first step towards one's treatment is to know what it
will involve.
This is partly the way to calculate how many grafts you may
require to give a non balding look - not a comb over alone
or very thin look.
Whether the patient can afford that many grafts or has that
much donor supply is an issue to be dealt after the principle
of optimum grafts has been understood.
Note:
This method is not meant as a substitute
to what your hair transplant doctor decides. It is merely
a method by which you may realize the approximate nos.
Hair line and temple areas have a much larger proportion of
1 hair grafts. Since the hair density (in the non balding
head) is similar in the hairline zone as compared to the scalp
donor areas, it means the no. of FUs is more.
If a person has 70 FUs per sq. cm. in the donor area (average
2.3 hair per FU), then his non balding hairline area is likely
to have as much as 150 grafts per sq. cm. (average 1.15 hair
per FU).
The front 1cm. (in people with a high degree of skin - hair
color contrast) to 0.5cm. (in people with lower degree of
skin hair color contrast and curly hair) is to be considered
the hairline zone for purposes of hair transplant and graft
estimates.
Thus, the prospective hair transplant patient should mark
out this hairline zone (possibly in conjunction with his hair
transplant doctor).
In this he has a lot of leeway in terms of planning a V shape
or a rounded hair line.
After measuring the area of the hairline zone in sq. cm. he
has to multiply that figure with 70.
Example:
Donor area FU density is 70 FU per sq. cm.
The patient has straight dark hair and a fair skin.
He measures the length of the proposed hair line as 20 cm.
The hairline zone area = 20cm. x 1 cm. =20 sq. cm.
Graft requirement for the hairline zone at 70 FU per sq. cm.
works out to
20sq.cm. x 70 FUs = 1400 FU grafts.
A similar approach has to be used in the temporal areas. Adding
the figure one obtains from the hairline zone to those we
calculated for the rest of the balding areas one gets the
total optimum graft requirement.
7000 + 1400 = 8400 grafts.
It goes without saying that a person with a higher or lower
FU counts in the donor area has to accordingly adjust his
calculations.
This mathematical model that i have proposed is a way of estimating
the graft requirements in conjunction with your hair transplant
doctor's advise in an objective way.
This is to safeguard against a salesman consultant who may
advise 1000 grafts to a person (who may actually require much
more) to get him started.
|
|
|
| 
|
|
| |
|
| |
|
| |
|
|
|
Not a good hair transplant
candidate.
|
Not a good hair transplant
candidate.
|
|
|
Minimum
requirement: 800 grafts.
Moderate requirement: 1400 grafts.
Optimum requirement: 2000 - 2500 grafts. |
Minimum
requirement: 1200 grafts.
Moderate requirement: 1800 grafts.
Optimum requirement: 2500 - 3000 grafts. |
|
|
Minimum
requirement: 2000 grafts.
Moderate requirement: 3000 grafts.
Optimum requirement: 4000 grafts. |
Minimum
requirement: 1800 grafts.
Moderate requirement: 2500 grafts.
Optimum requirement: 3500 grafts. |
|
|
Minimum
requirement: 3000 + grafts.
Moderate requirement: 4000 + grafts.
Optimum requirement: 6000 + grafts. |
Minimum
requirement: 3500 + grafts.
Moderate requirement: 4500 + grafts.
Optimum requirement: 6000 + grafts. |
|
|
Minimum
requirement: 6000 + grafts.
Moderate requirement: 8000 + grafts.
Optimum requirement: 10,000 + grafts. |
Minimum
requirement: 7000 + grafts.
Moderate requirement: 10,000 + grafts.
Optimum requirement: 15,000 + grafts. |
|
| |
|
|
|